This may be a shock, but price is probably only 25% of the decision making process when it comes to things like auto insurance. People are very concerned about claims, support, feeling good about the company, etc. Now, if your price is 25% higher, you'll never get a deal, but if it's within reach, with a name brand recognition, you'll write deals all day long.
Here is the catch.... you have to know your product, and how it competes with other carriers products. For instance, I don't go after singles in their low 20's with one car. I don't have a competitive advantage for that market, it's all about price. I do extremely well with married couples in their 30's (and above) with a home, and a few children. Basically, I target mainstream, middle-income America. These policies also tend to stay 'put' once written, which is what StateFarm, AllState, Farmers, etc are looking for.
Give me a call (PM me for the number) and I'll give you the ins and outs of some of this.
Dan
How do you approach your target market and how do you sell car insurance? I work for an independent agency and we write policies if we have the lowest price. We can't seem to get away from price. Any advice would be grand!