Chargebacks

Jack12345

Expert
42
Hey all,

Been in the industry since last September with FFL selling primarily FEX and some MP. Since the very beginning, it's been very tight for me paying my bills while trying to spend 3-5k/month on leads and dialing 10-15 hours per week and the few months that I have written 15-25k have resulted in some serious chargebacks (got about 10k debt now accrued over the past month and a half that forced me to have to get a full time 9-5 job).

This has been extremely frustrating as all of these chargebacks were some of my best clients (multiple sits, both husband and wife there or parent/child) on $1,500-2,500 policies that I thought were well placed/fit within the budget (most of them with Americo interestingly). Issued about 40k over the past 2-3 months that resulted in close to 19k of business falling off the books. Obviously my product placement/tying down the policies could get a lot better, but these all fell within the clients' budgets at the time.

Is this just par for the course in this niche (FEX and 20 times sold over FFL internet leads)? Felt like I've just been spinning my wheels the past 9 months and when I have successfully grinded out some good numbers it just ended in massive chargebacks that felt largely out of my control (obviously there's more that I could've done, I take full responsibility for that - just discouraged and wondering if this is the norm). Also, even those months that I have put up 20k plus of issue paid business, it felt like the entire model/system was sort of harassing clients 'I'm the local guy required to drop this off, I have to come out there,' jamming the appointment down their throat and multiple agents in the same area all calling prospects 15 plus times in a day and literally hundreds of times over multiple months. No disrespect to anyone but it honestly felt like a bunch of bottom feeder sharks in bloody waters all trying to get tiny little fish for $30-60/month.

I've been conflicted because I had tried to follow the FFL model to the best of my ability which resulted in this chargeback situation while I see all these ppl issuing 20-60k/month consistently. My intuition has told me from the very very beginning back in September that there is a much better way to do this business where I can work smarter rather than harder (sniper approach rather than shotgun). Aka targeting middle/higher income younger clients with IUL's, annuities, LTC and CV WL policies for debt free life, RE or business financing that would result in fewer chargebacks, much higher average commission, and most likely less market saturation as barrier to entry is a lot higher.

I understand digital marketing and FB ads after having spent a few thousand dollars on previous businesses before insurance, going through multiple biz/marketing coaching programs and currently working for a company that teaches people how to start marketing agencies - so I know I can figure out my own lead generation - I just never went all in with that b/c I didn't have the money (in retrospect I can see that I actually did) or full product knowledge to be able to effectively market.

Assuming others here will have some valuable thoughts on this all and how I might be able to move forward best, just looking for some potential feedback from others within the industry outside of the echo chamber I've been in (spend more money, make more dials, run more appointments, recruit 10 people for only 1 of them to stay long term, don't try to do your own marketing, etc.) Any thoughts appreciated.
 
Are you writing automatic bank withdrawals where the commission gets annualized and you get paid up front even though the insured is paying monthly? That's what's killing you. Stop doing it. Write quarterly or semi-annual payments and get your partial commission when it's earned. Then you don't have to give any back when the policy lapses.
 
If there are too many chargebacks most insurance companies will cancel your contract due to persistency problems. They don't tell you that when they recruit you. Then you can't outwrite the business, you actually have to cut a check to pay it back. Could be a bad situation.
 
Hey all,

Been in the industry since last September with FFL selling primarily FEX and some MP. Since the very beginning, it's been very tight for me paying my bills while trying to spend 3-5k/month on leads and dialing 10-15 hours per week and the few months that I have written 15-25k have resulted in some serious chargebacks (got about 10k debt now accrued over the past month and a half that forced me to have to get a full time 9-5 job).

This has been extremely frustrating as all of these chargebacks were some of my best clients (multiple sits, both husband and wife there or parent/child) on $1,500-2,500 policies that I thought were well placed/fit within the budget (most of them with Americo interestingly). Issued about 40k over the past 2-3 months that resulted in close to 19k of business falling off the books. Obviously my product placement/tying down the policies could get a lot better, but these all fell within the clients' budgets at the time.

Is this just par for the course in this niche (FEX and 20 times sold over FFL internet leads)? Felt like I've just been spinning my wheels the past 9 months and when I have successfully grinded out some good numbers it just ended in massive chargebacks that felt largely out of my control (obviously there's more that I could've done, I take full responsibility for that - just discouraged and wondering if this is the norm). Also, even those months that I have put up 20k plus of issue paid business, it felt like the entire model/system was sort of harassing clients 'I'm the local guy required to drop this off, I have to come out there,' jamming the appointment down their throat and multiple agents in the same area all calling prospects 15 plus times in a day and literally hundreds of times over multiple months. No disrespect to anyone but it honestly felt like a bunch of bottom feeder sharks in bloody waters all trying to get tiny little fish for $30-60/month.

I've been conflicted because I had tried to follow the FFL model to the best of my ability which resulted in this chargeback situation while I see all these ppl issuing 20-60k/month consistently. My intuition has told me from the very very beginning back in September that there is a much better way to do this business where I can work smarter rather than harder (sniper approach rather than shotgun). Aka targeting middle/higher income younger clients with IUL's, annuities, LTC and CV WL policies for debt free life, RE or business financing that would result in fewer chargebacks, much higher average commission, and most likely less market saturation as barrier to entry is a lot higher.

I understand digital marketing and FB ads after having spent a few thousand dollars on previous businesses before insurance, going through multiple biz/marketing coaching programs and currently working for a company that teaches people how to start marketing agencies - so I know I can figure out my own lead generation - I just never went all in with that b/c I didn't have the money (in retrospect I can see that I actually did) or full product knowledge to be able to effectively market.

Assuming others here will have some valuable thoughts on this all and how I might be able to move forward best, just looking for some potential feedback from others within the industry outside of the echo chamber I've been in (spend more money, make more dials, run more appointments, recruit 10 people for only 1 of them to stay long term, don't try to do your own marketing, etc.) Any thoughts appreciated.

Its the business model you are working within. Your agency has the agents selling high priced FE companies instead of competitive ones. Those are always going to have low persistency. What do you think is going to happen when any good agent comes in and quotes behind you? Mrs. Smith I can give you $3,000 additional coverage for what you are already paying. And Mr. Smith since you are a smoker your rate is going to have a HUGE rate increase in 2.5 more years BUT I can rewrite you with a company that will give you just as low of a premium and guaranteed for your lifetime.
Plus on top of that they give you a huge pay cut n most of your carriers. Your 120% is in name only. You are really on a 95% with most of your FE companies which is lower than other agencies pay. You are losing 20 to 30% to your Upline that other agencies allow you to keep. That's $800 to $1000 per week for the average agent writing $4,000 in premium.
But the worst offense is they are churning leads. Your agency does not assign a lead territory to you that is yours. They just have a free for all and recruit, recruit, recruit. They have no intention of any one individuals agent being successful. They just pile agent on top of agent so they can keep reselling leads over and over and they even want new green pea agents to recruit more agents. Lol how would that ever make sense for anyone except the managers at the top.
Get with an agency that has exclusive leads, exclusive lead territories, REAL training, competitively priced carriers, and no pyramid recruiting and really pays you the real 120% commissions on MOST FE carriers. There are plenty of them but you have to seek them out. Good agencies don't spam agents to death. They don't need to. Agents have to seek them out.
I recommend that you start your search with my agency FexContracting
But also look at Chris Smith, Matt Murray, (the Insurance Panel Guys) EFES, Matt Mungia, Todd King, Ben Boman, Jose Arteaga, etc.
You will have a WAY different experience with ANY good quality agency than a mass recruiter.
Call me any time if you would like to talk. I have helped thousands of agents understand the pieces of this biz that you don't currently understand. And I don't pitch anyone. The number is on my website. FexContracting.com
 
Have to agree with AdjusterJack. Take your commission AS EARNED for a while until you start to see some stuff stick. Also you have a statement of "Well placed/fit within the budget". The only GOOD life policy is one that stays on the books. Clients can usually add more if they feel a need. If they say they can budget $200/month, find coverage at $150 or $125/month. Get them used to missing the money but not MISSING anything. When the budget allows $200/month, as soon as something goes awry that client is looking to cut expenses and the life policy is usually the first to get stopped
 
Have to agree with AdjusterJack. Take your commission AS EARNED for a while until you start to see some stuff stick. Also you have a statement of "Well placed/fit within the budget". The only GOOD life policy is one that stays on the books. Clients can usually add more if they feel a need. If they say they can budget $200/month, find coverage at $150 or $125/month. Get them used to missing the money but not MISSING anything. When the budget allows $200/month, as soon as something goes awry that client is looking to cut expenses and the life policy is usually the first to get stopped
Going as earned is treating the symptom not the real problem. His business isn't sticking. That's the problem.
 
I've been conflicted because I had tried to follow the FFL model to the best of my ability which resulted in this chargeback situation while I see all these ppl issuing 20-60k/month consistently.

And you think all those people aren't seeing half of their business fall of the books?

You have to budget for it if you are going to use the FFL model of jamming folks into Americo policies. Heck, this is just the initial fall off. Just wait until your policies get to month 23 and Americo rescinds then and you get hit with multiple full year charge backs.

Have a good bankruptcy attorney in your cell phone contacts.
 
Is another IMO even going to offer a contract with a three month persistency of around 50 percent and almost 20k in debt. Not trying to knock you and I do not recruit, but if I did... I would be hesitant.
 
Back
Top